Hmm I'm not so sure about Rimmel. I've never used their liner before but I've used their mascara before. I'd recommend [link] for your eyes ^^ It's very safe and soft. My eyes are bad too and I have astigmatism. So this is lovely and works wonders ^^ Just be careful to keep it in a place that will stay cool or at room temperature because that sucker can melt pretty fast in heat! It's the only problem with it.